ICRAF Publication Detail Page

Publication Details

Journal Article
JA00670-17
Article TitleCertify and shift blame, or resolve issues? Environmentally and socially responsible global trade and production of timber and tree crops
AuthorDagmar Mithofer, Meine van Noordwijk, Beria Leimona and Paolo Omar Cerutti
Year2017
Journal TitleInternational Journal of Biodiversity Science, Ecosystem Services & Management
Volume13
Issue1
Pages72-85
Call NumberJA00670-17
KeywordsCertification; certifiability; issue–attention cycle; swing potential; global value chain; sustainability standards; governance; ecosystem services
Abstract:
Certification of adherence to social and environmental standards allows companies involved in the (global) trade of commodities to dissociate themselves from negative impacts in the public eye. It can go beyond compliance with legal requirements. Certification can be an attempt to shift blame to uncertified others, but it can also contribute to resolving the underlying issues of concern. We provide a framework for a study of when, where and how certification schemes emerge and evolve, with specific attention to the degree to which underlying issues get addressed. Three strands of literature are combined in this framework (1) the issue–attention cycle as a schematic representation of public concerns shaping policy responses; (2) the management swing potential defined as the gap between best and worst current production systems and the basis for defining standards and (3) global value chains that link distant producers and consumers, and the power relations along these chains, including standards and certification. Based on literature review, we introduce a set of four propositions that inform testable specific hypotheses. We outline questions for reviews, in subsequent papers of this issue, of the experience on timber, oil palm, coffee, cacao and
rubber as tropical-forest-margin commodities dominated by global trade.
Download file(s): Click icon to download/open file.
  File Size Description
download file 1894 KB Softcopy
Viewed in 329 times. Downloaded in 309 times.